×

La oferta termina hoy.Obtén un 30% de descuento en cualquier curso (excepto paquetes).

Termina en --- --- ---

Haltech vs Link

Ajuste práctico independiente

Mensajes del foro

Debate y preguntas relacionadas con el curso de Sintonización Práctica Independiente.

= Hilos resueltos

Autor
812 Vistas

Hi Gents,

I am looking for some information from people who tunes or tuned both Link G4X and Haltech Nexus ECUs.

I have a Plugin G4X right now in my 07 STi and I am quite happy with that, but now that Haltech introduced the user configurable CAN in the Nexus products, I am thinking if there are any benefits to swap to a Nexus S3.

Not counting I/O differences, I would appreciate any inputs on pros and cons or any major differences in how they and their NSP software work?

There is one thing that annoys me with the PCLink, which is during PC logging the refresh rate drops to single digit Hz number which seems to have an impact on the actual number of datapoints saved too, not only the visual refresh rate of the screen.

So, any similar watchouts with Haltech or the other way around, any advantages (like 32x32 tuning table resolution vs 22x20 in Link), better or worse idle control, cold start control, etc..?

Thanks in advance for the replies.

Béla

Both systems are great and if you have the car already setup and running on the Link then I personally don't think you'll gain much advantage switching to the Nexus. Thsta's not as dig at Haltech, just that you're almost comparing apples with apples. Your PCLink logging rate is unusual as I've been using these ECUs (in one variant or other) for most of my career and never seen the frequency drop to a single digit. Normally this should be something like 50Hz and a single digit would definitely be problematic for logging. This is an issue because it's one area I think Link probably dfo a better job of than Haltech (their built in logging).

Honestly beyond this issue (which i'd suggest running past Link support), I would not think that the juice here would be worth the squeeze making that change.

Thanks Andre. I understand what you are saying, and I tried to sort this out through the Link forum quite some time back, but I wasn't able to, though Adam provided the help he could.

On the other hand, I understand I compare apples to apples, but that's how it is supposed to be, no? And I only wanted to understand if there is anything that people like more in the Haltech world or the Link.

Anyhow, I ended up ordering a Voodoo Pro for a couple of reasons. The help in PCLink is much more detailed then in the NSP (and that would make the learning curve with the Haltech quite painful as even your worked example in the standalone tuning course is quite basic), there is the Link forum which is already proved to me very helpful, the custom can setup can handle composite frames and has the I/O that I need (and I need a lot ;) ), the realtime PC logging with all the timeplots (which is actually causing my issues I think with the refresh rate, but in the NSP those are restricted to 60s only time span) and who knows, maybe one day I'll swap an FA24 into my 07 sti lol.

On the Haltech side though I really liked that you can add an internal pullup to all the analog inputs, the lot of generic sensors you can add to the config and that most of thimes you can configure multiple sensors or actuators/controls very easily - forexample multiple fuel pumps (I know you can do that with the link too but it's not like simply flipping a toggle switch under the FP setup). I really liked the overall concept of how you can turn on/off the different functions, not to mention how easy and illustrative the wiring configuration is, including the I/O report which is awesome as work your way through the wiring.

I sell and support both, at this point its application to me. Link has always tended to have more polished PnP solutions - some have been great, some have been good, others have been annoying and (for me) Haltech's have been my go to for 'street/track' oriented clean sheet solutions - I also tend to prefer Haltech peripherals and now that they've announced a single ecosystem transmission control solution for 8HPs that may be on par or better than a Maxx install you'll probably start seeing more.

Solemos responder en un plazo de 12 horas (a menudo antes).

¿Necesitar ayuda?

¿Necesitas ayuda para elegir un curso?

¿Está experimentando problemas con el sitio web?

¿O necesita ponerse en contacto con nosotros por cualquier otro motivo?