Forum » General Tuning Discussion » How 'unfrequent' can knock occur?

How 'unfrequent' can knock occur?

General Tuning Discussion

Forum Posts

Courses

Blog

Tech Articles

Discuss all things tuning in this section. News, products, problems and results. 

= Resolved threads

Page 1
Author
215 Views

Hey guys,

i have a question regarding knock. Car is a Honda Integra K20A with a doctronic ECU (identical to Hondata kpro).

I know that K Engine is prone to show knock which is engine noise.

So: If a knock happen, is it happen like nearly all the time under the same circumstances --> reproduceable?

With other words: If i have a knock-event that is NOT reproduceable, is it engine noise?

Example: I enabled "Flash MIL on knock" and headed for a very spirited mountain drive. During my 10 Minute raceing, i saw the MIL flash two times. I tried to replicate that with the Laptop connected (i only road tune) but it never happened.

So - yea, whats true?

Thanks :)

Knock is more likely to occur with high combustion temps. Did you replicate those temps / loads?

You don't mention if the engine is normally aspirated, or running forced induction. I would not be concerned about the occasional knock event under hot conditions with a normally aspirated engine. That is exactly what the knock system is for, adjust the timing if the conditions show increased knock.

Hello David,

its a lightly tuned N/A engine. I tried to replicate but i only saw the MIL flashing while racing so im not entirely sure at which load / rpm it happened. I did a ton of highway pulls afterwards and drove it kinda spirited for one tank of gas and didnt had this happened again.

On my map the Knock-retard-logic is disabled since i heard its "best practise" for Honda K20 engines (very noisy)